Why Does Rockingham County Public Schools
Purchase Apple Macintosh Computers?
by Joe Hill, Director of Math and Technology
Quite often I am asked to justify why Rockingham County Public
Schools continues to buy Macintosh computers. While the standard for
business may be the Windows PC, the standard for education in RCPS is still
the Apple Macintosh. Historically, Apple has a substantial market share of the education
market. But we don't buy Macs
just because other schools do. Here are my top reasons why the
Macintosh platform is the best for Rockingham County Public
Schools:
- Price. Apple has traditionally given
substantial discounts to the education market. The
total cost of ownership for educational
computers from Apple, including purchase price, technical support,
maintenance, setup time, training time, network management, years
of useful service, etc. is MUCH lower than that of Windows.
- Service. Rockingham County Public Schools
employs several Apple-certified technicians. Our technology staff
has exceptional ability to service Apple products. RCPS is also an
authorized service center which means our staff performs all
repairs including warranty work for which Apple reimburses us.
- Apple's commitment to education. Unlike other
vendors, Apple frequently provides training and consulting to
schools at no cost. Apple has a full-time Virginia educational
representative and a systems engineer who keeps school divisions
informed of new products, discounts, solutions to problems,
etc.
- Management tools. Inexpensive software
available from Apple makes it easy to set up menuing/security
software for workstations. MacManager and Workgroup Manager
software makes it easy for students and teachers to launch
applications and retrieve files but impossible to destructively
"trash" files. Other software including Apple Network
Administrator Toolkit and Apple Remote Desktop allows labs to be quickly set up and
easily managed. Timbuktu software allows all RCPS LANs to
be managed from downtown Harrisonburg or from home. Individual
workstations' screens can be viewed from remote sites.
- Fewer hacking issues. Macintosh servers are
more difficult for malicious users to damage. High school students
are notorious for beating security systems installed on PC's but
are more adept at hacking them than Macs. We have experienced this
frequently in our high school (Windows) business labs.
- Fewer virus issues. Nearly all viruses are directed at, and
only affect, Windows computers. RCPS spends almost no time nor money on virus protection
for Macs whereas we spend lots of both for our Windows computers.
- Years of useful service. We have eight year old
Macs that still work fine on our networks.
- Compatibility to Windows Macintosh computers
can read media formatted for Windows. So a student can create a Word, Excel, or
Powerpoint file at home, bring it in to school on a USB memory device, CD, or via the web-based digital lockers provided for students and the
school's Mac can read it without an issue. It can be edited using the Mac version of
Word, Excel, or Powerpoint and saved back to the Windows media.
- Uniformity. Apple was the early leader in
education and all school divisions, including Rockingham,
purchased Apple products. By staying with this platform,
uniformity is ensured from school to school. This greatly helps in
providing support and training. In Rockingham County, instructional computers at elementary and middle school are 100%
Macintosh. High school networks are cross-platform. This
uniformity saves us money because, for example, where we have
already purchased district licensing for instructional software,
additional workstations can use this software at no additional
cost.
- Durability. Apple products are long lasting.
There are over 4500 computers in Rockingham County as of 2009. If
exactly 99% work great each day, that still means 45 per day would
require service. And a staff of eleven technicians cannot support 45
per day requiring service. So, our Apple products are running at
better than 99% efficiency, superior to our experience with other
brands.
- What our teachers ask for.Thanks to the support and
training we've been able to provide, teachers are
now comfortable with the Mac and with the RCPS network. RCPS
employs two former teachers as Technology Instructional
Specialists and seven more as Instructional Technology Resource Teachers
who ensure that teachers are trained in using our
hardware and software. What better situation could we have than
the type of computers in classrooms and labs which teachers
requested and nine exceptionally competent professionals on staff
to show them how to use them?
But shouldn't students learn how to use the
Windows operating system?
Of course they should. Car owners should know how to drive
Chevrolets and Hondas. That's why all of our high school
business and technology education labs have Windows workstations. But it is MORE important for all students to learn
basic keyboarding, word processing, spreadsheet, data base, and
internet skills. Remember, all of our Macs are outfitted with Microsoft Word,
Excel, Powerpoint, and a web browser. These skills will last far longer than a particular
operating system like Mac OS X or Windows XP. And those skills can
be taught on any computer...our preference is Macintosh.